Last month, Taylor Swift and her team took some time away from interpolating novelty songs into disappointing singles and turned their attention to intimidating a little-known blogger. Swift took issue with Meghan Herning of PopFront, who accused Swift of dogwhistling to white supremacists in a post with the headline “Swiftly to the alt-right: Taylor subtly gets the lower case kkk in formation.” Herning, who wrote that the lyrics of Swift’s recent single “Look What You Made Me Do” were perhaps a knowing message of solidarity with the alt-right, received a letter on Oct. 25 from William J. Briggs II, who represents Taylor Swift. They ordered an immediate retraction of Herning’s blog. Here are that blog’s highlights, as picked out by Briggs’s letter: 1) “Taylor’s lyrics play to [a] subtle, quiet white support of a racial hierarchy;” 2) that there are similarities between Ms. Swift and Adolf Hitler; 3) that the “lyrics [of “Look What You Made Me Do”] are the most explicit in speaking to white anger and affirming white supremacy;” and 4) that Ms. Swift’s purported silence regarding white supremacy means she supports Donald Trump and identifies with the white supremacist/al-right [sic] movement. The rest of the letter ( in full here) tries to flay Herning for implying Swift is a Nazi just because she’s been very private about almost any political statements. Briggs calls the allegation “preposterous,” and writes that the blog’s “a baseless fiction masquerading as fact,” which is a phrase with some flair. Here’s the attorney’s big attempt at a haymaker towards the end: One thing is certain: you are requiring Ms. Swift, but not any other celebrity or musician, to loudly denounce white supremacy and you do not accept her previous condemnations as good enough. Given your apparent animus and malice toward Ms. Swift, the intent to cause harm to Ms. Swift is clear. The final paragraph of the letter is a weird intimidation tactic: This is a confidential legal notice and is not for publication. Any publication, dissemination or broadcast of any portion of this letter will constitute a breach of confidence and a violation of Copyright Act. You are not authorized to publish this letter in whole or in part absent our express written authorization. Briggs sent this dick-swinging letter to inform Herning that Taylor Swift is not a Nazi supporter, then informed Herning she’d be breaking the law if she made that information public. Look, there’s not much anyone can say about “Look What You Made Me Do.” Just like how any artist who samples, say, The Jackson 5, will usually end up with a great track, anyone who digs into Right Said Fred will probably come out with something similarly ridiculous. There’s some cool analysis to be done on what’s otherwise a terrible song if you want to get conspiratorial and deep into the internet, but treating the song as a serious, intentional ode to Charlottesville’s tiki-torchers might be a bit much. (Herning is absolutely correct, however, when she writes that “silence in the face of injustice means support for the oppressor.”) More importantly, a millionaire like Swift sending a threatening letter to a blog like PopFront is absurd, both for its irrationality and its scary imbalance of power. Thanks to that threatening letter and only to that letter, I read a blog post about how Taylor Swift is subtly flirting with the alt-right that I otherwise never would have seen. (Seriously, PopFront has just 100 Twitter followers at the time of this writing). It’s a textbook example of the Streisand Effect. Even if, in this particular instance, the real effects are small or even nonexistent, Briggs’s letter is a scary reflection of the current climate that prevails in journalism and criticism. That is a climate in which the powerful can cut off access or scare people into complying when they don’t like a story. Rich people shouldn’t get to manipulate the legal system so they can determine for themselves what is and isn’t publishable. If Herning didn’t have the support of the ACLU, that’s likely just what would have happened here.
Related Posts
Norwich City boss Chris Hughton has called on his players to build on their West Ham win when they travel to St James Park on Saturday.
Norwich climbed out of the Premier League s relegation zone by coming from behind to win 3-1 against West Ham before the international break.
That result ended a winless run of five matches in which they had shipped 18 goals and were embarrassed 7-0 by Manchester City and eased the pressure on Hughton.
And ahead of Saturday s trip to Newcastle United, Hughton is hopeful his side can now go on a winning run.
It was great to see the reaction to the Manchester City defeat against West Ham, said Hughton, who managed Newcastle from June 2009 to December 2010.
St James Park is a great place to go and play football. We have to go …
Joe Hart believes Premier League champions Manchester City have now established themselves as one of English football s superpowers.
City held off the challenge of Liverpool and Chelsea to land their second title in three seasons last term, scoring an incredible 102 goals in the process.
The Etihad Stadium club won their first top-flight crown in 44 years in 2012, and have now finished in the top two for three campaigns in a row.
Sheikh Mansour s takeover in 2008 heralded a new era at the club, with global stars such as Sergio Aguero, Yaya Toure and David Silva all being brought to Manchester since then.
And City s haul of two Premier League titles, the FA Cup and the League Cup in the last three years is evidence enough for Hart that they are now among the coun…
Champions League-winning goalkeeper Keylor Navas is hell-bent on staying at Real Madrid despite the arrival of Thibaut Courtois.
Navas has helped Madrid to three successive European crowns but the Costa Rica international s future is in doubt after the Spanish giants agreed a deal with Chelsea for Courtois.
Belgian star Courtois will sign a six-year contract at the Santiago Bernabeu, however, Navas has no plans to leave Madrid.
Of course, and I say this with force, I have the same desire to leave than I have to die, Navas told the Onda Cero programme.
Navas moved to Madrid from Levante in 2014 – the LaLiga powerhouse triggering the 31-year-old s €10million buyout clause.
His future has always been speculated amid Madrid s pursuit of Manchest…
Fabio Capello has accused Bayern Munich s stars of failing to give their all under Carlo Ancelotti, who was sacked by the Bundesliga giants in September.
Bayern coasted to the league title in Ancelotti s first season in charge, but his tenure was blighted by rumours Die Roten s key players were unhappy with his methods.
An inauspicious start to this campaign culminated in a woeful showing in a 3-0 Champions League defeat to Paris Saint-Germain and spelled the end of Ancelotti s reign.
Veteran coach Jupp Heynckes, who led Bayern to the treble in 2012-13, returned to the Allianz Arena to take over until the end of the season and the club have lost just once in all competitions under his leadership.
Capello suggested that it is no coincidence and believes Ba…
Gareth Bale and Cristiano Ronaldo have been named among the first nominees for this year s Ballon d Or.
The Real Madrid duo join Sergio Aguero, Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang and Gianluigi Buffon as the first names to be revealed on the 30-man shortlist.
The overall list of names put forward for the prize is being announced in five-man groups in alphabetical order throughout Monday.
The Ballon d Or and the FIFA World Player of the Year awards merged in 2010 to become the FIFA Ballon d Or, but that partnership came to an end this year, allowing both prizes to return to their original formats.
Bale and Ronaldo enjoyed excellent campaigns for Madrid last season, especially after Zinedine Zidane took charge in January, helping fire the club to a second Champions L…
Frank Lampard said Chelsea fans can dream of winning the Premier League title, though he warned the Blues must focus on improving after moving top of the table.
Chelsea climbed to the top of the summit ahead of Sunday s north London derby between Tottenham and Arsenal, and Liverpool s clash with Wolves after overcoming Leeds United 3-1 on Saturday.
Olivier Giroud, Kurt Zouma and Christian Pulisic scored for Chelsea, who moved a point clear of rivals Tottenham and defending champions Liverpool, albeit temporarily.
Chelsea are 13 games unbeaten across all competitions and nine in the Premier League amid a growing sense of belief at Stamford Bridge, where a limited number of fans were allowed to attend the match in the midst of the coronavirus pandemic.
The …
Jurgen Klopp agreed with suggestions Mohamed Salah could soon be considered one of the best players in the world, but the Liverpool manager feels comparisons with Lionel Messi will not help the forward.
Salah scored four times in the 5-0 win over Watford at Anfield on Saturday, taking his tally to 27 Premier League goals in a prolific first season on Merseyside.
Such has been the impact of the Egypt international upon returning to England from Roma, one reporter put it to Klopp that the former Chelsea striker, along with Barcelona star Messi, is one of the game s top talents.
Yes, I think Mo is on the way, he said.
That s good. I don t think Mo wants or anybody wants to be compared with Lionel Messi.
He [Messi] is the one that is doing what he…
Verdict: Brazil Draw no Bet
Best Odds:
Bookmaker:
Fresh from the third successive draw in international friendlies, World Cup holders Germany take on probably the number one candidates for the trophy in Russia. Having hammered 2018 World Cup hosts Russia, Brazil will want to gain an extra psychological advantage over other title contenders and at the same time get some revenge on die Mannschaft for the embarrassing 7-1 loss at the 2014 tournament.
Germany
One of world’s most famous national teams have enjoyed plenty of success under Joachim Low, lifting the 2014 World Cup and 2017 Confederations Cup trophies, while finishing third at the Euro 2012 and Euro 2016. Die Mannschaft are showing no signs of slowing down with plenty of quality footballers c…
Juventus could include Arthur Melo in a deal to sign Gabriel from Arsenal in the summer of 2023, according to . The report in the Italian news outlet has claimed that former Serie A and UEFA Champions League winners Juventus have long wanted Brazilian defender Gabriel and could make a bid for him at the end of the season.
The plan of the Italian giants is to include Brazil international midfielder Arthur Melo in the deal. The former Barcelona star is on loan at Liverpool at the moment. The 26-year-old moved to the Merseyside club on loan from Juventus in the summer of 2022 and is scheduled to stay at Anfield until the end of the season.
Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta really likes Arthur, according to the report, and this is why Juventus believe that a deal involving the B…
Chelsea have signed Marcus Bettinelli on a two-year deal after his contract with neighbours Fulham expired.
The goalkeeper made 120 appearances over a decade at Craven Cottage but will now provide back-up to Edouard Mendy and Kepa Arrizabalaga.
Bettinelli, 29, will replace Willy Caballero, who left Chelsea as a free agent after just two appearances in all competitions last season.
The new man has limited top-flight experience, having made his Premier League debut for Fulham against Burnley in August 2018. That game started a run of seven league starts under Slavisa Jokanovic.
Bettinelli s form over that stretch earned a call-up to Gareth Southgate s England squad, though he did not make an appearance for the Three Lions.
Marcus Bettinelli has …